Order Thanksgiving

Order Thanksgiving Pies

Order your favorite desserts by calling ahead and picking them up at Market Street Diner and Bakery on the date of your choice. Order your Thanksgiving desserts by Saturday, November 18th.

Call to Order Pies

Pie and popular Cake sizes:

  • Medium Pies – $14.99
  • Large Pies – $22.99
  • 8″ 3 layer Carl’s Cake – $19.99

Our most popular Thanksgiving Flavors:
Pumpkin Spice Cake
Chocolate Mocha Cake
Pecan Pie
Peanut Butter Silk Pie
Cranberry Apple Pie
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Pie

But you can special order any of our pie flavors or specialty treats with 72 hours notice.
Visit our Pies menu to see all of our flavors and Carl’s Cakes menu for all of Carl’s signature flavors.

The perfect end to your Thanksgiving dinner
Turkey may be the star, but let’s be honest, dessert is what everyone is waiting for this Thanksgiving. Every year, our bakery goes into overdrive baking your favorite pies and cakes for you to take home and enjoy at your family celebration.

Last minute pie orders
Need a Thanksgiving pie in a pinch? You’re in luck! We’ll have a limited number of 9” pies available through Sunday, November 19th – Wednesday, November 22nd. Call us to reserve Apple, Pumpkin, Cherry, Strawberry Rhubarb, Oreo, and French Silk pies for Wednesday, November 22nd pick up.

Roll the dessert dice
We’ll have extra desserts in store on the Tuesday and Wednesday preceding Thanksgiving. Desserts are available on a first come, first serve basis and quantities are limited.