Holiday Treats

Madison’s best holiday treats
The holidays can be stressful enough. Instead of spending hours baking, avoid the hustle and bustle and order your holiday treats from Market Street Diner & Bakery! Whether you’re entertaining or need a unique hostess gift, we have the perfect treat for your holiday party…and they’ll think you baked all day!

Order your holiday treats by Tuesday, December 19th
All holiday dessert orders must be placed by Tuesday, December 19th to have them in time for Christmas. Order your favorite desserts by calling ahead at 825-3377. Market Street Diner & Bakery is open daily from 7:00 am–9:00 pm. 72-hour notice is appreciated. We offer complimentary delivery on orders over $150.

Give a cake…and eat one too.
Custom Carl’s Cake
Want the best? Order a Carl’s Cake for the holidays! Personalize it for your recipient. Price dependent on size.

Pumpkin Spice Cake
Everyone loves pumpkin spice—especially in a cake layered with cream cheese. Serves 12-16. 29.99

Yule Log
Chocolate roll cake filled with Bavarian cream and iced in chocolate buttercream. A Christmas tradition for centuries! Serves 10. 29.99

Cookies that aren’t cookie-cutter.
Hand-Dipped Sugar Cookies
Our signature hand-dipped sugar cookies can be personalized and individually bagged for giving. These cookies can also be customized with an edible image. 2.99 each

Cookie Platters
Dazzle everyone with an assortment of scratch-made favorite cookies and sweets. Our talented bakers make each cookie by hand!
Small 24.99 Medium 39.99 Large 49.99

Hand-decorated Sugar Cookies
Mint Brownies
7-layer Bars
Peppermint Meltaways
Rugelach
Russian Tea Cakes
Butter Cookies
Peanut Butter Blossoms
Rum Balls

Holiday Pies
A slice of our pie is the perfect way to finish any holiday meal! We have some favorites, but any of our pies are available for preorder, and all are sure to please your friends and family.
Small 14.99 Large 22.99

After Dinner Mint
Apple
Caramel Apple Walnut
Chocolate Pecan
Cranberry Apple
Cherry
French Silk
Pecan
Pumpkin
Pumpkin Pecan Chocolate Chip