The heart of the community
In our overflowing bakery case, you’ll find an amazing array of pies, cheesecakes, jumbo cupcakes, cookies, seasonal treats, and breakfast pastries that no other diner can match. All of our offerings are made from scratch daily right here in the diner. Cap off your meal with a bakery treat or bring your favorite desserts home to help celebrate any occasion. To place a bakery order in advance, call 825-3377. 72-hour notice is appreciated. Delivery or pickup is available.
Home of Carl’s Cakes.
Our bakery is also home to Carl’s Cakes, Madison’s most recommended wedding cakes. If you’ve been to a Madison-area wedding in the last 30 years and marveled at how truly great the cake was, chances are it was a Carl’s Cake. Since 1985, Carl Loeffel and his crew have been baking wedding cakes that make you come back for seconds - and thirds. And since 2009, Carl’s Cakes has been a part of Market Street Diner and Bakery.